A Summary Of Recent Appellate Decisions From Pennsylvania (September 2006)

Pennsylvania State Court Decisions

1. Civil Litigation
1.1. Automobile Insurance
1.1.1. Cars for Hire
*Supreme Court

♦ Prudential Property & Casualty Ins. Co. v. Sartno, No. 163 MAP 2005 (August 21, 2006)

Holding: An insureds use of his private vehicle to deliver pizza does not render the automobile a car for hire and does not trigger the exclusionary provision of the insurance policy.

1.1.2. Uninsured & Underinsured Motorist Arbitration
* Superior Court

♦ The Hartford Ins. Co. v. OMara, 2006 PA Super 236 (August 29, 2006)

Holding: Under the Uniform Arbitration Act of 1980, when the application or construction of an insurance policy provision is at issue, the dispute is within the exclusive jurisdiction of the arbitrators. A court will take jurisdiction only when the claimant attacks a particular provision as: (1) contrary to a constitutional, legislative or administrative mandate; (2) against public policy; or, (3) unconscionable.

♦ Nationwide Insurance Co. v. Schneider, 2006 PA Super 219 (August 17, 2006)

Holding: Section 1733 of the MVFRL specifies the priority for recovery of underinsured motorist benefits, but neither mentions nor requires exhaustion of limits. When an insured settles a claim in contravention of a policys consent-to-settle clause, an insurer must show that its interests are prejudiced.

1.1.3. Subrogation
* Supreme Court

♦ Wirth v. Aetna U.S. Healthcare, No. 28 EAP 2005 (August 22, 2006)

Holding: Pursuant to the Pennsylvania Health Maintenance Organization Act, 40 P.S. 1560(a), a health maintenance organization is exempt from complying with the anti-subrogation provision of the Pennsylvania Motor Financial Responsibility Law.

1.2. Medical Malpractice Claims
1.2.1. MCARE Act
* Superior Court

♦ McManamon v. Washko, 2006 PA Super 245 (August 31, 2006)

Holding: The Medical Care Availability and Reduction of Error Act does not apply to injuries not caused by medical negligence.

1.3. Sovereign Immunity
1.3.1. Real Property & Sidewalks Exceptions
* Commonwealth Court

♦ Reid v. City of Philadelphia, No. 1572 C.D. 2005 (August 3, 2006)

Holding: A street owned by a municipality that is designated a Commonwealth highway continues to be owned by the municipality. If a person is injured on a municipal sidewalk that adjoins a designated highway, the municipality remains the owner of the sidewalk and the sidewalk is, therefore, within the right of way of a street owned by the municipality for purposes of analyzing governmental immunity under the Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act.

♦ LoFurno v. Garnet Valley School District, No. 2082 C.D. 2005 (May 3, 2006)

Holding: A belt sander, designed to be bolted to the floor, that is not hardwired or permanently attached to the floor or to a dust collection system, is personalty, and not a fixture under the real property exception to governmental immunity under the Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act.

2. Civil Procedure
2.1. Appeal
2.1.1. Conflict Between Federal & Pennsylvania Law
* Superior Court

♦ Trombetta v. Raymond James Financial Services, Inc., 2006 PA Super 229 (August 22, 2006)

Holdings: 1.The standards of review of an arbitration award under the Pennsylvania Uniform Arbitration Act are not preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA).

2. The standards of review under the FAA cannot preempt the Pennsylvania standards for review of arbitration awards unless the Pennsylvania standards of review frustrate the underlying objectives of the FAA because standards of review are an inherently procedural mechanism used to facilitate judicial resolution of controversies after the underlying arbitration agreement has been enforced in accordance with the FAA.

3. Common law arbitration standards of review do not violate the core objective and principles underlying the FAA. Pennsylvania law governs the question of whether parties can impose de novo review on trial courts by virtue of contractual agreements.

4. De novo review clauses contained in arbitration agreements are unenforceable as a matter of law in Pennsylvania.

♦ Joseph v. Advest, Inc., 2006 PA Super 213 (August 8, 2006)

Holding: The provision of the Federal Arbitration Act permitting a party three months to challenge an arbitration award is procedural. Pennsylvanias 30-day deadline (under either the Uniform Arbitration Act or common law arbitration) for contesting arbitration awards applies to such appeals, and appeals filed more than 30 days after the entry of the award are untimely.

2.2. Capacity to Sue
* Superior Court

♦ George Stash & Sons v. New Holland Credit Co., LLC, 2006 PA Super 206 (August 2, 2006)

Holding: The Fictitious Name Act provides that an entity that fails to register its fictitious name shall not be permitted to maintain any action in a Pennsylvania tribunal. Where, as here, a person or entity knows the identity of the persons with whom he or she is dealing, he cannot assert the lack of capacity to sue under the Fictitious Name Act.

2.3. Collateral Source Rule
* Superior Court

♦ Simmons v. Cobb, 2006 PA Super 222 (August 16, 2006)

Holding: The collateral source rule does not preclude a plaintiff from introducing evidence of the receipt of Social Security Disability benefits. Rather, the collateral source rule, which is intended to protect tort victims, provides that payment from a collateral source shall not diminish the damages otherwise recoverable from the wrongdoer. In this case, plaintiff sought to introduce evidence of receipt of SSD benefits.

2.4. Forum Non Conveniens
* Superior Court

♦ Wright v. Aventis Pasteur, Inc., 2006 PA Super 203 (August 2, 2006)

Holding: In determining whether to dismiss a case pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S.A. 5322(e) based on forum non conveniens, the trial court must consider two important factors: (1) a plaintiffs choice of the place of suit will not be disturbed except for weighty reasons, and (2) no action will be dismissed unless there is an alternative forum available to the plaintiff. As Superior Court acknowledges this decision diverges from the apparent trend in recent forum non conveniens decisions ... toward dismissing cases brought in Pennsylvania where another forum is available.

2.5. Interlocutory Appeals
2.5.1. Generally
* Supreme Court

♦ Pridgen v. Parker Hannifin Corp., Nos. 8 & 9 EAP 2005 (August 22, 2006)

Holding: In order for a trial court Order to be a collateral order under Pa.R.A.P. 313 and appealable as a matter of right the following three factors must be present:

1. The Order must be separable from and collateral to the main cause of action;
2. The right involved is too important to be denied review and must involve rights deeply rooted in public policy going beyond the particular litigation at hand; and,
3. The question presented is such that if review is postponed until final judgment in the case, the claim will be irreparably lost.

1.1.1. Trade Secrets
* Superior Court

♦ Crum v. Bridgestone, 2006 PA Super 230 (August 23, 2006)

Holding 1: This decision contains the same holding relating to collateral orders as Pridgen (above).

Holding 2: Pursuant to Section 757(b) of the Restatement (2d) of Torts and Pennsylvania law, in order to determine whether particular information is to be given trade secret status, a court should consider the following factors:

1. The extent to which the information is known outside of the business;
2. The extent to which the information is known by employees and others involved in the business; and,
3. The extent of measures taken to guard the secrecy of the information. Order must be separable from and collateral to the main cause of action.
For a court to determine whether a protective order is appropriate under Pa.R.Civ.P. 4019(a)(9), the discovery standard should embrace both (1) relevance and necessity, and (2) a balancing of need versus harm. Once a party establishes that the information sought is a trade secret, the burden shifts to the requesting party to demonstrate by competent evidence that there is a compelling need for that information and that the necessity outweighs the harm of the disclosure.

1.1. Judgment by Default
* Superior Court

♦ State Farm Insurance Co. v. Barton, 2006 PA Super 210 (August 7, 2006)

Holding: After a responsive pleading is filed, even if untimely, a judgment by default cannot be entered because the responding party is no longer in default.

1.2. Settlement
* Commonwealth Court

♦ Brannam v. Reedy, No. 2590 C.D. 2005 (August 14, 2006)

Holding: An evidentiary hearing is required when one party disputes the existence of a settlement agreement or its binding effect, and is the appropriate procedure even when there is a written agreement signed by counsel if it is alleged that counsel lacked the authority to bind his client. There must also be a hearing when a settlement is vacated by court order or enforced by court order. A hearing must be held even if the trial court has intimate knowledge of the facts as a result of a pre-hearing conference because a trial courts recital of facts is not a substitute for a full record. A hearing must also be held, despite filing a petition and answer, even if no party requests one.

1.3. Transfer From Federal Court to State Court
♦ Falcone v. The Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania, 2006 PA Super 241 (August 30, 2006)

Holding: Pursuant to 42. Pa.C.S.A. 5103, a party may transfer a case from federal court to the appropriate state court when the federal court lacks diversity jurisdiction. The date of the federal filing becomes the date of the state filing for purposes of the applicable statute of limitations. To comply, a party must promptly file a certified transcript of the final judgment of the federal court and related pleadings in a Pennsylvania court or magisterial district. A party does not comply with the statute by filing a new complaint in state court.

2. Unemployment Compensation
2.1. Necessitous and Compelling Reason to Quit
* Commonwealth Court

♦ Brunswick Hotel & Conference Center, LLC v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review), No. 464 C.D. 2006 (August 23, 2006)

Holding: Elimination of health care benefits constitutes a substantial change in employment terms and serves as a necessitous and compelling reason for a claimant to resign from employment, thus entitling the claimant to unemployment compensation benefits.

3. Workers Compensation
3.1. Appellate Review
* Supreme Court

♦ Trimmer v. Workers Compensation Appeal Board (Monaghan Township), No. 58 MAL 2006 (August 3, 2006)

Holding: The Commonwealth Court (and presumably the Workers Compensation Appeal Board) may not substitute its determination of the facts and credibility of witnesses for the Workers Compensation Judges proper assessments. This per curiam Order summarily reverses the Commonwealth Courts decision because determination of facts and credibility is solely within the province of the Workers Compensation Judge.

3.2. Hearing Loss/Employer Liability
* Commonwealth Court

♦ Hayduk v. Workers Compensation Appeal Board (Bemis Co., Inc.), No. 230 C.D. 2006 (August 11, 2006)

Holding 1: When an employer (Company A) purchases the assets, but not the liabilities, of another company (Company B), including the plant where the claimant worked, and the purchase specifically excludes any of Company Bs workers compensation liabilities that arose prior to the purchase of the assets, Company A is not liable for any work-related hearing loss that occurred prior to its purchase of Company B.

Holding 2: Under Section 306(c)(8)(iv) of the Workers Compensation Act,audiometric testing for a work-related hearing loss must conform to applicable OSHA standards. It is the employers burden, however, to establish that an occupational hearing loss is attributable to a previous employer. When, as here, the employer fails to meet this burden, it remains liable for all of a claimants compensable hearing loss.

3.3. Impairment Rating Examinations
* Supreme Court

♦ Dowhower v. Workers Compensation Appeal Board (Capco Contracting, Inc.), No. 542 MAL 2003 (August 11, 2006)

Holding: The Supreme Court has granted claimants Petition for Allowance of Appeal and will, presumably, address the issue of whether an employer may request an Impairment Rating Examination before the 104-week period in Section 306(a.2)(1) of the Workers Compensation Act.

3.4. Physical Examinations
* Commonwealth Court

♦ Knechtel v. Workers Compensation Appeal Board (Marriott Corp.), No. 140 C.D. 2006 (August 24, 2006)

Holding: Pursuant to Section 314(a) of the Workers Compensation Act, when an employees physician attends an employer-requested physical examination, the employee is entitled, at employees expense, to have a health care provider of his or her own selection participate in such examination. Participation is limited to attendance and observation.

Havertown Pa. Lawyer Daniel J. Siegel is the creator Pa. Legal Links (http://www.palegallinks.com) and founder of Integrated Technology Services (http://www.itsllconline.com). To subscribe/contact Dan Siegel, visit http://www.danieljsiegel.com or email subscribe@danieljsiegel.com.Girlie Myspace Quote
Chanel Sun Glasses
Online Exotic Pet Store
Electrical Code Books
10 Holiday Movie Top
3 Play Price Retail Station Suggested
Airport Hobby Shuttle
Pharmacy Technician Online
Personalized Pool Cue
10 Chart Hit Mtv Top
Remote Water Meter
1 Fish Gallon Tank
Barney Before Christmas Night
0 Apr Credit Cards
Cheat Game Play Sims Station
Condo Craigslist Florida Orlando
Big Mtv Pic Rob
Whistler Ski Packages
Misdemeanor Charges
Boston Store Wisconsin
Lawyer Mesothelioma Michigan Peritoneal
Cyber Cafe Management Software
Automatic Horse Waterer
Child Entertainment Family Orem
Daytona Beach Gmc
1 Com Internet Marketing Solution Stop
Tonys Restaurant Houston Tx
Secured Business Loan
Usa Today College Baseball
Z
07 2006 Almanac Farmer Outlook Winter
The Firehouse Bar
Physics Homework
Bbva Puerto Rico
Prince Of Tennis Wonderful Day Mp3
Dating Older Personals Woman
04 Dance Recital
Ll
Carnation Breakfast Bar
Boiler Gas Home Hot Natural Water
Augustine House Light St
Bike Oregon Shop Southern
Mover Dublin
How Many Baseball Team Are In The American League
Guy Philippe
Total Gym Pilates
Maritime Museum San Diego
2 Week Detox Diet
Royal Bank Of Canada Visa Card
A New Pair Of Glasses
Apple Ipod Canada
1 Engineering Gas Handbook Natural Petroleum Standard Volume
Milwaukee Tots Toy
Philidelphia Cream Cheese
Wedding Program Example
03 Jetta
Industrial Cleaning Machines
Final Fantasy 2 Guide
Chicago Condominium Hotel
Diet Healthy Loss Weight
1 Pip Spread Forex Trading Platform
College Financial Aid For Dummy
Cafe Denim Hard Man Rock Shirt
02149 Everett Girl In Soccer Team
Buy Cart Dog Hot
Baseball
Aau Assault Basketball Dc
Bubble Tea Toronto
Approved Car Finance Uk
10 Hottest Careers
How To Write A Business Plan Nonprofit
Abc Glasses Safety
Illinois Health Insurance Quote Quote
1973 Act Disability Individual Rehabilitation
20 Air Cheap Online Ticket
Agent Bradenton Florida Insurance Job
04 05
Camera Nikon Underwater
Agency Directory School Texas Travel
Cacee Jessica Shoes Simpson
Shopping
King Night
1 800 Directory Phone
Georgia Lpn Schools
Cinderella Dress Style Wedding
Forex Fund
1 Gb Flashdrive
1 3 Carat Diamond Earring
Boot Randolph Yakety Sax
001 001 Celebrity Diet Keyword Miva R
Dress Game Up Wedding
Interrelationship Diagram
Mobile Pet Grooming Nj
2 Player Pool Game
Cheap Discount Mattress
Ipod
Hat Novelty Wholesale
Restraint Of Trade
Hayward Heat Pump For Pool
Egypt Travel Package
Boot Replica Ugg
Disney Holiday Package World
000 Based Business Home Start
Victorian Lamp
By Canada Home Ontario Owner Sale
Nike College Basketball Jersey
Seven Wonders Ancient World
Espn Fantasy Baseball
30th Birthday Party Supply
Prophecies Of Nostradamus
Dvd Editor
Cat Shirts
Rm250 Parts
Health Insurance Average Rate
School
Fuel Oil Dealer
Receiver Receiver Satellite Satellite Tv Tv
Fort Worth Gas Prices
Free Insurance Life Sales Technique
0 Accept Business Card Credit
Last Minute Flight Booking
Forex Prediction Software
Flood Florida In Insurance
Buying Stock Online
20588 College Football Ticket
Kitchen
Gaskets Compression
Bad Bank Credit Loan Signature
Book Apple Vacation Online
1 Com Internet Marketing Promotion Services Site W
1960s Attendant Flight Uniform
Living Locator Organized Store
Large Leaf
Mugatu Costume
Cash Flow Instant System
Banking Finance Job Lawyer
Am Dvd Soccer
10 Bucket
Perky Pet Humming Bird Feeder
Power Rangers Dino Thunder Costume
Business Internet Internet Marketing Strategy
Huntington Beach Bar Pub
Magazine Online Wood
Boot With Fur On Top
Deuce Bigalow European Gigolo
California Costume Disney
World Cafe Santa Monica
Footwear
Duplicate File Finder
100 Greatest Rock Songs
Download Driver Satellite Toshiba
More Britney
Adventures Of Sherlock Holmes
10 Code Friend Myspace Top
1 Acb
Case Equipment Farm
Cisco Cable
Kid Fur Hat
Chocolate Skateboarding
Cooked Cream Custard Homemade Ice
Cafe Dallas Express
By Cash Johnny Leigh Photograph Wiener
A Full Body Massage Washington Dc
2007 Flight Simulator
1881 1902 City City Directory Directory England New State
Cosmetic Laser Niagara
Amerihost Inn Suite
Christmas Picture Frame
Air Air Air Cheap Cheap Flight Fligths Iceland Iceland Iceland Ticket Travel
0824 Brita Dispenser Water
2006 Caribbean Inclusive Vacation
Adult Toy Affiliate
Forex
Contact Glasses Shopping
1 2 3 Bath Kitchen
Florida Arts And Entertainment
Boat Dealer Exceptional Sailing
N
Gardening
Professional Cover Letter
22nd Street Jazz Cafe
Grill Out Of Gas Tank
Laser Hair Removal Tampa
Kitchen Island Leg
1 Home
Unlade
1 Gb
Los Angeles Dodger Baseball Ticket
Global Warming In Artic Could Wipe Out Polar Bears By
0 Car Deal Finance New
Aging Anti Care Skin Supplement
Diet Food Healthy Raw
Variable Whole Life Insurance
Discount Shaw Carpet
02 03
Denver Mtv Real World
Satellite Ready Televisions
Lacoste Golf Shirt
Bag Exporter In India Plastic Shopping
Depression Food Help
Flower Girl Dress And Shoes
Apply For A Master Card Credit Card Online
10 Bracelet Gold Jewelry Karat Tanzanite White
Dog Bounty Hunter Dvd
2001 Banos California Los Obituary
Find Location Vending
Fish Gold Pond
10 Company Health Insurance Top
Stop Program
10 10 Long Distance Numbers
Cell Phone Deal With Free Phone
2004 Beach Summer Vacation
0 Odor Pet
Court House Riverside
Specs Of 2007 Camaro
Refractive Surgery Tv Commercial
100 Tea Tree Oil
Sony Digital Camera Charger
2 Mtv Subterranean
Texas Small Business Grants
10 10 Number
01 Porsche
Code Myspace Overlapping Text
Royal Furniture Gallery
Sexy Evening Party Dress
0 2007 60 Gt Mustang
07 Cup Icc World
Catholic Christian Dating Site Web
Health
Discount Dress Gown Wedding
0a Business Home Mlm Opportunity Work
Company Estate Florida Naples Real
Country Line Dance Instructions
Id Wallets
Apply For 501 C 3
1400 Willow Condominium Louisville Ky
Unique Birthday Gift Online
Accounting Finance Software
Agency Dating Single Uk
05 Ford Mustang
Indoor Chaise Lounges
10 Inch Girl Bike
Abc College Coverage Football Regional
Charlotte Apartment Guide
Combi Avatar
Drugs Detox
Bbc Radio 2 Online
Tucson Television
History Merengue Dance
Michael Copon
Home Heating Oil Furnaces
Gospel Jesus Johns Mystical New Perspective Portrait
Christmas Door Decorating Idea
03 Cheap Flight International
Carpet Tool Wholesale
Pa Used Car Dealers
Antonio Costume Rental San
Nicolette Sheridan Bikini
Airwalk Skateboarding Shoes
Kid Fitness Tip
Breathtaking Image Satellite
Disneyland Hotel Reservation
Planet Neptune Moons
Niche Philosopher
Second Home Mortgage
Golf Club Review
Gas
1 Bracelet Ct Diamond Tennis
Vitamin C Molecular Structure
Weight Gain Birth Control
America Bird Field Geographic Guide National North Revised Updated
Carpet Cleaners Floor Steam
Generator Bicycle
06 Party Pool Summer
Santa Claus Photos
Boss Snow Plow
Sms Per Crm
Bass Pro Outlet Store
Man Perfume Versace
Ii
Swimming Pool Contractor Detroit
Engine Gas Lonoke
1 800 Yellow Pages
Maui Jim Sun Glasses Hilo
Shark Fishing Cancun
Dowling Magnets
Pci Video Capture Card
Implement Customer Relationship Management
Amosite Malignant Mesothelioma 0 11 Mesotheliom
Basketball Players Tattoo
03 Cobra Mods
Rca Television
Sims Cheat House Party On Pc
Best Hair Conditioner
100 Estate Real Remax
Realty Brooklyn
In Mallorca Pollensa Sale Villa
1 Apartment Cat Rent
The Farm Channel 5
0f America Bank Banking Online
How To Build A Chaise
Game Mario Tennis
Mtv True Life Episode
Management Stress Tips
2nd Generation Ipod Shuffle Skin
Vintage Jewelry And Book
10 Best Camera Digital Top
0 Auto Loans
Account Bank Offshore Private
10 Battle Ben Cartoon Network Ready
Secret Garden Canopy Bed
Power Conversions
Allstate Insurance Quote
Hugo Perfume For Woman
1 16 Toy Tractor
Florida Home Retirement
Kentucky State Basketball
Crown Steel
Fuel Oil Furnace Troubleshooting
Travel
1 5 Attic Attic Dollanganger Flower Flower In In Series Through
Arab Celebrity Picture
Celebrity Baby Shop
Predator Costume
Attorney Driving Drunk Hawaii
Special Education Advocacy
10 Fast Make Money Ways
Pink Panther Cartoon Wallpaper
Pool
Magic Ring Pilates
Dental Hmo Insurance
11 September Conspiracy
Ideal World Tv Shopping